Todd:Chem3x11 ToddL5

From OpenWetWare

Revision as of 07:36, 5 May 2012 by Matthew Todd (Talk | contribs)
Jump to: navigation, search

Home        Contact        Internal        People        Papers        Research        Teaching        Links        News        Construction       


Contents

Chem3x11 Lecture 5

Still under construction Sat May 5.

This lecture is about Neighbouring Group Participation (sometimes also called Anchimeric Assistance).

(Back to the main teaching page)

Key concepts

  • Groups/atoms with available electrons positioned near the carbon involved in a substitution reaction can influence the reaction
  • Such Neighbouring Group Participation (NGP) can dictate the stereochemical outcome of a reaction
  • Different stereoisomers of starting material can give very different outcomes from NGP processes

Simple Examples of NGP

A sulfur atom in the 2-position of an alkyl halide greatly increases the reactivity of that alkyl halide.

Scheme 1: Effect of a Sulfur Atom in the 2-Position of an Alkyl Chloride
Scheme 1: Effect of a Sulfur Atom in the 2-Position of an Alkyl Chloride

This is not terribly surprising when you realise that S is a good nucleophile. Though we give these kinds of influences the fancy name of neighbouring group participation (NGP) or anchimeric assistance, keep in mind it's just intramolecular nucleophilic attack. The reaction goes through a high energy intermmediate (a sulfonium ion), and you might want to pause and think what that will mean in terms of its rate behaviour and whether this is an SN1 or SN2 reaction.

Scheme 2: Role of the Sulfur Atom in NGP
Scheme 2: Role of the Sulfur Atom in NGP

These kinds of structures (2-chlorothioethers) are sometimes called mustard gases, and were used with terrible effect as chemical weapons in World War I. The sulfonium ion can react with many biomolecules, yet if it reacts with water it produces HCl which can burn and blister the skin. This is an unusual example - chemistry is typically a Force for Good.

Besides effects on rates of reactions, NGP has very considerable influence on reaction stereochemistry, which we'll now look at.

Stereochemical Effect of NGP

What Happens in a Simple Case

If we imagine a molecule that could display NGP, but for some reason did not, then a regular SN2 nucleophilic displacement would go with inversion of configuration. Obviously the diastereomer of the starting material behaves the same way.

Scheme 3: Direct SN2 Nucleophilic Displacements without NGP
Scheme 3: Direct SN2 Nucleophilic Displacements without NGP

In fact what happens is this:

Scheme 4: Nucleophilic Displacements with NGP
Scheme 4: Nucleophilic Displacements with NGP

Whatever you do, don't memorize this. We need to look at the mechanism, when everything will become clear and obvious.


Why That Happens

Let's take the top example first, and redraw the molecule so that the internal nucleophile (SMe) is antiperiplanar to the tosylate, since this is the geometry required if there is going to be NGP.

Scheme 5: Redrawn Versions of the Starting Material (R,S)-Isomer
Scheme 5: Redrawn Versions of the Starting Material (R,S)-Isomer

Now let's do the internal displacement, and draw the sulfonium ion in each case. Like any regular SN2 reaction (which this is not, because there's only one molecule involved, but the idea is the same) there is inversion at the centre where the attack happens.

Scheme 6: Formation of the Reactive Intermediate Sulfonium Ion
Scheme 6: Formation of the Reactive Intermediate Sulfonium Ion

Notice how the intermediate has a kind of symmetry - it's chiral, but has an axis of rotational symmetry. The molecule is C2 symmetric, which is an important kind of symmetry in organic chemistry. The upshot is that it doesn't matter where the acetate attacks, the end result will be the same molecule. But let's make sure:

Scheme 7: Attack of Acetate on C2-Symmetric Sulfonium Ion
Scheme 7: Attack of Acetate on C2-Symmetric Sulfonium Ion

Now let's look at the other diastereomer of the starting material and see why the outcome is so different. Running through the same analysis, we arrive at intermediates that look similar, but which have a different kind of symmetry. Now it matters which carbon the incoming acetate goes for. There won't be a preference for one rather than the other because... the intermediate is achiral - it's meso - something you came across in first year. There are still stereocentres, but the molecule overall is achiral.

Scheme 8: Formation of meso Sulfonium Ion
Scheme 8: Formation of meso Sulfonium Ion

When the acetate attacks at the two different carbons, we produce two enantiomeric products (in equal amounts, hence a racemate overall).

Scheme 9: Racemic Product Formed from meso Sulfonium Ion Intermediate
Scheme 9: Racemic Product Formed from meso Sulfonium Ion Intermediate

So this has been a rather lengthy worked example to show how important it is to include NGP participation in your analysis of a reaction. We've analyzed an example where sulfur is the group responsible for the NGP, but there are others that can do the same thing, such as groups based on oxygen, nitrogen and even aromatic rings, giving oxonium, nitronium and phenonium ions as intermediates.

Scheme 10: Other Groups can Effect NGP
Scheme 10: Other Groups can Effect NGP



The Licence for This Page

Is CC-BY-3.0 meaning you can use whatever you want, provided you cite me.

Personal tools