User:Jason Morrison/Thoughts on semantic wikis

From OpenWetWare

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(initial page import from gdocs, jmorrison thoughts about sem wiki)
Line 1: Line 1:
-
= Introduction to the ideas of semantic web and the utility of an RDF+Wiki combination +
+
== Introduction to the ideas of semantic web and the utility of an RDF+Wiki combination ==
 +
 
* Watch quick vids (10m total) at http://eyaloren.org/
* Watch quick vids (10m total) at http://eyaloren.org/
* Read Wikifying an RDF Editor from http://hypergraphs.de/
* Read Wikifying an RDF Editor from http://hypergraphs.de/
-
= Semantic Wikis and their ideas =
+
== Semantic Wikis and their ideas ==
http://ontoworld.org/wiki/Semantic_Wiki_State_of_The_Art_Paper
http://ontoworld.org/wiki/Semantic_Wiki_State_of_The_Art_Paper
Line 23: Line 24:
N.B. An interesting discrimination Eyal Oren (semperwiki) makes is between letting the RDF embedded in a page specify attributes of _that page_ versus specify attributes of the _object that the page is about_.
N.B. An interesting discrimination Eyal Oren (semperwiki) makes is between letting the RDF embedded in a page specify attributes of _that page_ versus specify attributes of the _object that the page is about_.
-
== Rhizome ==
+
=== Rhizome ===
* http://ontoworld.org/wiki/Rhizome  
* http://ontoworld.org/wiki/Rhizome  
* http://www.liminalzone.org/static/semwiki2006-28.pdf
* http://www.liminalzone.org/static/semwiki2006-28.pdf
-
== SemperWiki ==
+
=== SemperWiki ===
Local, single-user, but interesting concept.  I needed a custom hacked .deb to run on Ubuntu 7.10 (see http://jayunit.net/2008/1/28/installing-redland-1-0-7-from-source-on-ubuntu-7-10, and my version of semperwiki-hacked.deb, not currently online)
Local, single-user, but interesting concept.  I needed a custom hacked .deb to run on Ubuntu 7.10 (see http://jayunit.net/2008/1/28/installing-redland-1-0-7-from-source-on-ubuntu-7-10, and my version of semperwiki-hacked.deb, not currently online)
Line 39: Line 40:
* http://eyaloren.org/pubs/semdesk2005.pdf
* http://eyaloren.org/pubs/semdesk2005.pdf
-
== Others ==
+
=== Others ===
* "Platypus [22], WikSAR [2], Semantic MediaWiki [23] and IkeWiki" --http://eyaloren.org/pubs/semwiki2006.pdf
* "Platypus [22], WikSAR [2], Semantic MediaWiki [23] and IkeWiki" --http://eyaloren.org/pubs/semwiki2006.pdf
-
= Ideas about producing views on RDF =
+
== Ideas about producing views on RDF ==
* "Fresnel is a simple, browser-independent vocabulary for specifying how to display RDF models.":http://www.w3.org/2005/04/fresnel-info/manual/
* "Fresnel is a simple, browser-independent vocabulary for specifying how to display RDF models.":http://www.w3.org/2005/04/fresnel-info/manual/
  - "Java engine for parsing and applying Fresnel configurations.":http://simile.mit.edu/wiki/Fresnel
  - "Java engine for parsing and applying Fresnel configurations.":http://simile.mit.edu/wiki/Fresnel
Line 59: Line 60:
** "Turtle - Terse RDF Triple Language":http://www.dajobe.org/2004/01/turtle/
** "Turtle - Terse RDF Triple Language":http://www.dajobe.org/2004/01/turtle/
-
= Versioning =
+
== Versioning ==
* http://ontoware.org/projects/semversion/ exists, and uses a quad-store, but I think that's overkill.
* http://ontoware.org/projects/semversion/ exists, and uses a quad-store, but I think that's overkill.
* It's probably best (for our purposes) to build it into the wiki/tool layer, as i don't think it's necessary to track versioning in the document semantics layer
* It's probably best (for our purposes) to build it into the wiki/tool layer, as i don't think it's necessary to track versioning in the document semantics layer
Line 77: Line 78:
idea: produce view-layer editing widgets that embed into a rich text editor using fckedit/tinymce/yui-rte as a base.
idea: produce view-layer editing widgets that embed into a rich text editor using fckedit/tinymce/yui-rte as a base.
 +
--[[User:Jason Morrison|Jason Morrison]] 22:05, 4 February 2008 (CST)

Revision as of 00:05, 5 February 2008

Contents

Introduction to the ideas of semantic web and the utility of an RDF+Wiki combination

Semantic Wikis and their ideas

http://ontoworld.org/wiki/Semantic_Wiki_State_of_The_Art_Paper

Eyal Oren is doing some very interesting work, and points out naive shortcomings in the majority of existing semwikis. Quote:

   Recently several Semantic Wikis have been developed, such as Platypus [22],
   WikSAR [2], Semantic MediaWiki [23] and IkeWiki [20]. These Wikis answer
   these questions in a rather limited way: (a) they allow only simple annotations
   of the current Wiki page; (b) they do not formally separate the page and the con-
   cept that it describes; and (c) they do not fully exploit the semantic annotations
   for improved navigation.

-- http://eyaloren.org/pubs/semwiki2006.pdf


There are a variety of subtly different implementations for embedding RDF in wikis and vice-versa, with a variety of end goals being entertained. (So, it's important to remember to keep our goals in mind when choosing among them!)

N.B. An interesting discrimination Eyal Oren (semperwiki) makes is between letting the RDF embedded in a page specify attributes of _that page_ versus specify attributes of the _object that the page is about_.

Rhizome

SemperWiki

Local, single-user, but interesting concept. I needed a custom hacked .deb to run on Ubuntu 7.10 (see http://jayunit.net/2008/1/28/installing-redland-1-0-7-from-source-on-ubuntu-7-10, and my version of semperwiki-hacked.deb, not currently online)

Web:

Paper:

Others

Ideas about producing views on RDF

- "Java engine for parsing and applying Fresnel configurations.":http://simile.mit.edu/wiki/Fresnel
- "Longwell is a web-based RDF-powered highly-configurable faceted browser.":http://simile.mit.edu/wiki/Longwell

Data [exchange] formats

Versioning

  • http://ontoware.org/projects/semversion/ exists, and uses a quad-store, but I think that's overkill.
  • It's probably best (for our purposes) to build it into the wiki/tool layer, as i don't think it's necessary to track versioning in the document semantics layer

User Interface

Regardless, SB-specific UI may be helpful (see later section)

Ideas for a structured, SB-specific semwiki prototype:

  • Q: Is there an RDF schema/ontology for SB?
    • A: not yet, but the BBF working group will at least talk about it, and the workshop in Washington this spring might have some ideas. I hope you can come to that. We could present a paper or poster on the structure of D2, or maybe even demo it. -Macowell 1/28/08 1:19 PM

idea: produce view-layer editing widgets that embed into a rich text editor using fckedit/tinymce/yui-rte as a base. --Jason Morrison 22:05, 4 February 2008 (CST)

Personal tools